Understanding Narcissism: More Than Meanness or Spite. It’s Complicated and Nuanced

Narcissism, often misunderstood, extends beyond mere meanness or spitefulness. It’s a complex personality disorder that can significantly affect interpersonal relationships.

Narcissism Unveiled

Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) is characterized by a persistent pattern of grandiosity, a deep need for admiration, and a lack of empathy for others. Individuals with NPD often have an inflated sense of self-importance and a preoccupation with fantasies of unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty, or ideal love.

But let’s be clear: narcissism is not synonymous with someone being merely mean or spiteful. Mean individuals might show deliberate unkindness, while spiteful people might seek to annoy or hurt others out of resentment. Narcissists, however, are distinct in their consistent patterns of self-centeredness, entitlement, and disregard for other’s feelings and needs.

Symptoms of Narcissism

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5), published by the American Psychiatric Association, characterizes Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) by the following criteria:

Grandiosity with expectations of superior treatment from others
Fixated on fantasies of power, success, intelligence, attractiveness, etc.
Self-perception of being unique, superior and associated with high-status people and institutions
Needing constant admiration from others
Sense of entitlement to special treatment and to obedience from others
Exploitative of others to achieve personal gain
Unwilling to empathize with others’ feelings, wishes, or needs
Intensely jealous of others and the belief that others are equally jealous of them
Pompous and arrogant demeanor

Please note that according to the DSM-5, for a diagnosis of narcissistic personality disorder to be made, an individual must meet five or more of these criteria.

However, diagnosis should be performed by a qualified professional, as it requires a comprehensive evaluation and the application of clinical judgment.

According to the DSM-5, the prevalence of Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) in the general population is estimated to be approximately 0.5% to 1%. However, it is worth noting that the prevalence might be higher in certain settings such as clinical populations or in certain professions where assertive or dominant traits are highly valued or beneficial.

It’s important to remember that these numbers are estimates, and actual prevalence may vary depending on the population and diagnostic methods used. Additionally, many people with narcissistic traits or behaviors may not meet the full criteria for NPD, and therefore wouldn’t be included in these prevalence estimates.

Understanding the Roots of Narcissism

Although narcissistic personality disorder (NPD) is thought to have roots in a complex interplay of genetic and environmental factors, narcissism the specific causes are not well understood. However, some theories suggest that it can be traced back to early life experiences, particularly those related to one’s caregivers and attachment figures.

One common theory is that narcissism may develop as a response to childhood neglect or abuse, or from inconsistent parenting where care and attention were given unpredictably. For example, parents who are excessively adoring and overindulgent one moment, and excessively critical and dismissive the next, could inadvertently promote the development of narcissistic traits in their children. Over time, these children may learn to overemphasize their own importance and develop a defensive sense of superiority to protect themselves from feelings of inadequacy or insecurity.

Narcissistic individuals often grow up in families where vulnerability is viewed as a weakness. This could lead them to hide their feelings of inadequacy or rejection behind a façade of indifference or superiority. Moreover, narcissists may have faced criticism or dismissal of their emotional needs in childhood, leading to a deep-seated sense of worthlessness. To compensate, they may adopt narcissistic behaviors in an attempt to gain the validation and acceptance they craved but did not receive.

It’s important to note that not everyone who experiences these kinds of childhood circumstances will develop narcissism. Personality development is complex and influenced by many factors, including an individual’s genetic predispositions and their specific reactions to environmental stressors.

As always, diagnosis and understanding of such complex psychological conditions should be left to qualified mental health professionals. If you or someone you know seems to be struggling with symptoms of covert narcissism, it may be beneficial to seek out the help of a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist

Different forms of narcissism

Malignant Narcissist

A malignant narcissist is considered to be more harmful and destructive than an individual with ‘typical’ narcissistic traits. While they share many of the characteristics of NPD, such as grandiosity, a lack of empathy, and a need for admiration, malignant narcissists also exhibit antisocial traits, including a disregard for the rights of others, deceitfulness, manipulation, and a lack of remorse.

Some distinguishing characteristics of malignant narcissists include:

Severe Self-Centeredness: Like individuals with NPD, malignant narcissists believe they are superior to others and have a strong sense of entitlement. However, their self-absorption is typically more extreme and can result in neglect or abuse of those around them.
Lack of Empathy: Malignant narcissists have a profound inability to empathize with others. They are often indifferent to the feelings, needs, or suffering of others and may even take pleasure in causing pain.
Manipulative Behavior: Malignant narcissists are highly manipulative and exploit others to achieve their own ends without remorse or regret.
Aggression and Sadism: Malignant narcissists are often more aggressive than ‘typical’ narcissists and may exhibit sadistic tendencies. This means they derive pleasure from inflicting pain or humiliation on others.
Antisocial Behavior: They may also demonstrate a consistent pattern of disregard for, and violation of, the rights of others. This could include behaviors such as lying, deceit, manipulation, and a lack of remorse for their actions.

Overt Narcissism

Overt narcissists represent the stereotype most people envision when they think of narcissism. They display a grandiose sense of self-importance and superiority, showing off their achievements, expecting praise, and demanding the spotlight. Their need for admiration and lack of empathy for others are readily apparent. Their behavior can be construed as arrogant, envious, and entitled.

Covert Narcissism

Covert narcissists, on the other hand, also known as vulnerable or closet narcissists, may seem like a paradox. Unlike their overt counterparts, covert narcissists might come across as sensitive, introverted, and insecure. However, they share the same core characteristics of narcissism: a sense of entitlement, lack of empathy, and a deep-seated need for admiration.

Unlike the overt narcissist’s conspicuous grandiosity, the covert narcissist’s sense of superiority is less apparent and more insidious. They may present themselves as a victim, misunderstood, or special, fantasizing about their unrecognized talent or uniqueness. They may harbor fantasies of rescuing others, excelling in their field, or finding an ideal love, which in turn, feeds their sense of being ‘special’ or ‘misunderstood’.

Covert narcissists may often feel neglected or overlooked, leading to feelings of resentment and a desire to take revenge on the world that has failed to recognize their superiority. They can be highly defensive and extremely sensitive to criticism, often responding with what is called “narcissistic injury” – intense anger or humiliation.

A covert narcissist may be more difficult to recognize, often leading those in their lives to question their own sense of reality. For this reason, let’s look at a typical portrait of a covert narcissist.

Let’s imagine a character named Faye.

Faye is a striking individual, always immaculately dressed and carrying an air of charisma that’s hard to ignore. She’s vivacious, flirty, and appears to have a wide social circle full of people who are drawn to her charm.

Faye is a master at creating quick, superficial relationships. She starts off strong, showering new acquaintances with attention, praise, and kindness – a process often referred to as “love bombing.” This instant warmth and connection make her irresistible, causing people to quickly consider her a close friend or confidante.

At home, Faye’s controlling nature is more evident. Her partner, often left in the shadows, has long learned to cater to her needs and demands. She sees her partner’s income as her own, spending lavishly on high-end fashion and expensive cosmetic procedures to maintain her appearance. Despite their financial struggles, Faye’s focus remains on her image, viewing her appearance as her ticket to the recognition and admiration she craves.

Criticism is not something Faye handles well. Any comment on her spending habits or behavior is met with instant defensiveness. Faye skillfully flips the conversation, proclaiming herself to be a victim, and accusing others of not understanding her or being envious. This tactic often leaves her partner feeling guilty, further enabling her to maintain control.

Beneath her glamorous exterior and vivacious personality, Faye is an embodiment of a female covert narcissist. Her need for admiration, her lack of genuine empathy, her victim-playing, and her controlling nature all speak to this. Despite her seemingly confident exterior, she is constantly seeking validation from external sources.

Faye has a peculiar way of dealing with illnesses, particularly those of her children. Rather than treating them as unfortunate incidents to be dealt with quietly and privately, Faye seems to exploit these situations as a means to gather sympathy and attention. She dramatically narrates every cough, fever, or rash, presenting each as a near-catastrophic event that she’s courageously managing.

This behavior extends to her own health as well. Faye has a history of exaggerating minor ailments or non-existent ones, turning them into major health crises. She frequently shares these stories with others, weaving narratives of her resilience and bravery in the face of such adversities. These tales are yet another means to elicit admiration and sympathy, positioning herself as the ever-struggling, ever-enduring heroine.

Faye’s tendency to dramatize illnesses serves two key purposes. Firstly, it grants her the attention and sympathy she craves. Each sympathetic nod or concerned comment is a testament to her perceived uniqueness and significance. Secondly, it allows her to maintain control, particularly within her household. Her alleged health issues or those of her children often serve as convenient excuses to evade responsibilities or to justify her excessive spending on health treatments and procedures.

This manipulative exaggeration of illnesses adds another layer to Faye’s covert narcissism. It paints a picture of a woman so entrenched in her need for admiration and control that she willingly distorts reality, turning common incidents into dramatic tales of struggle and survival. It is a strategy that not only maintains her position in the spotlight but also further binds her family to her needs and whims.

Faye’s manipulation extends beyond just illnesses and crises. She has a keen eye for family dynamics and is adept at playing family members against each other. She stokes misunderstandings, miscommunications, and minor disagreements, twisting them into major conflicts. By doing so, she manages to keep everyone off balance and focused on their issues with each other, rather than her behavior.

While Faye claims to be the peacemaker, she is often the instigator, subtly fueling conflicts under the guise of trying to resolve them. This behavior not only keeps her in control but also provides her with a sense of superiority. As family members grapple with their disputes, Faye stands aloof, viewing their struggles as proof of her superiority and their dependency on her.

This behavior is typical of a covert narcissist like Faye. Her constant need for superiority and control drives her to manipulate those around her, turning family relationships into a battlefield of her making. Any threat to her perceived superiority is met with fierce resistance and malice, making it extremely difficult for anyone to confront or challenge her. Her tactics are insidious, often leaving those around her confused, divided, and uncertain about the reality of their experiences.

Faye’s manipulative behaviors are often veiled by her charm and superficial warmth, making it incredibly difficult for those around her to identify her as a covert narcissist. The realization of her true nature can indeed take years, even decades, to fully manifest.

Covert narcissists like Faye are masters of deception. They construct a façade of sympathy, charisma, and victimhood that masks their manipulative and controlling behaviors. Faye’s love bombing at the onset of relationships, her ability to present herself as the victim, and her knack for diverting blame away from herself all serve to deceive those around her.

At first, people might interpret her actions as eccentricities or individual quirks. Her extravagant spending might be seen as a love for fashion, her control over her husband may appear as a balance of power in their relationship, and her manipulation of illnesses could be perceived as an excessive concern for health.

However, as the years pass, patterns start to emerge. The continuous cycle of love bombing followed by emotional distancing, the persistent avoidance of personal responsibility, the constant need for admiration, the manipulation of family members – these behaviors start forming a puzzle that, when pieced together, paints a clear picture of covert narcissism.

In the face of this realization, many might grapple with feelings of confusion, betrayal, and even guilt for not recognizing the signs sooner. It’s crucial to remember that covert narcissists, like Faye, are adept at manipulation and deceit. It’s their proficiency in concealing their true nature that allows them to maintain control and feed their need for superiority and admiration. Covert narcissists like Faye are highly skilled at maintaining their carefully constructed facades. They are adept at manipulating others’ perceptions to ensure they are seen in the light they prefer.

If those around her continually acquiesce to her demands and behaviors, Faye’s true nature may never be fully revealed. This is because constant acquiescence serves as a validation for Faye. It reinforces her belief in her own superiority and confirms her perception that she is deserving of special treatment.

Confrontation or questioning could potentially disrupt Faye’s façade, prompting her to reveal her more manipulative and malicious behaviors. However, in the absence of such challenges, she can continue maintaining her charming disguise indefinitely. In this context, Faye’s covert narcissism functions as a self-perpetuating cycle. As long as those around her continue to cater to her whims and accept her behavior without challenge, Faye can keep her true nature hidden, maintaining the illusion of the charismatic, victimized heroine she portrays herself to be.

It’s worth noting that the perpetuation of this cycle often leads to significant emotional and psychological harm for those close to Faye. In order to protect themselves, it’s crucial for them to recognize the signs of covert narcissism, establish strong boundaries, and seek support from mental health professionals if needed.

The realization, when it comes, is the first step in dealing with a covert narcissist. It allows individuals to re-evaluate their relationship with the narcissist, establish firm boundaries, and seek support when needed. It’s a challenging journey, but one that eventually leads to understanding and recovery.

Navigating Covert Narcissism

Dealing with a covert narcissist can be particularly challenging because their behaviors may initially draw sympathy rather than alerting to the presence of narcissism. However, strategies such as the following can help guard against getting entangled in their manipulation.

Establish boundaries: Clearly communicate what is acceptable behavior in your relationship. This might be difficult as narcissists often don’t respect boundaries, but it’s an important step.
Don’t take it personally: Remember that a narcissist’s behavior is about them, not you. Their lack of empathy and need for admiration are manifestations of their disorder.
Practice self-care: Emotional involvement with a narcissist can be draining. Prioritize your wellbeing and engage in activities that reduce stress and enhance your mood.
Seek support: If you feel overwhelmed, consider seeking help from a mental health professional. They can provide strategies to manage your relationship and maintain your mental health.
Consider your options: In some cases, distancing yourself from the narcissistic individual might be the best course of action. Remember, you have a right to be in healthy and respectful relationships.

Recognizing the varying presentations of narcissism, like malignant, overt and covert types, offers a more nuanced understanding of this complex personality disorder. By doing so, it equips us with the knowledge to interact more effectively with individuals who exhibit narcissistic traits, while safeguarding our own emotional well-being.

For more information on Narcissism:

Books:
“The Wizard of Oz and Other Narcissists: Coping with the One-Way Relationship in Work, Love, and Family” by Eleanor Payson
“Disarming the Narcissist: Surviving and Thriving with the Self-Absorbed” by Wendy T. Behary
“Will I Ever Be Good Enough? Healing the Daughters of Narcissistic Mothers” by Karyl McBride
Websites:
Mayo Clinic’s Overview on Narcissistic Personality Disorder: Mayo Clinic NPD
Psychology Today’s Narcissism Topic Page: Psychology Today
Medline Plus’ resource on Narcissistic personality disorder: Medline Plus
Videos:
Dr. Ramani Durvasula’s YouTube Channel, which covers a variety of topics related to narcissism: Dr. Ramani’s Youtube Channel
Support Groups:
The Narcissist Family Files offers a list of online support resources for people dealing with narcissists: Narcissist Family Files Resources

Remember that while these resources can provide valuable insights and advice, they are not a replacement for professional help. If you are dealing with a situation involving narcissism and it’s causing distress, consider reaching out to a mental health professional for personalized support and guidance.

For those interested in booking a 1, 2, or 3-hour workshop covering a variety of mental health topics can write to me here for more information.

Those who would like more information and/or to secure a spot at The Healing Journey Retreat in Mexico can sign up for more information here.

Follow LJB and Associates Counseling Services and Laurie on Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram, Youtube, and visit her website for more info!